OSHA and MSHA Raise Penalty Fees

In 2015, Congress passed the Federal Civil Penalties Inflation Adjustment Act. It was passed to improve the effectiveness of civil penalties and to maintain their deterrent effect. The Act requires agencies to adjust their level of monetary penalties and to make subsequent annual adjustments for inflation no later than January 15th of each year.

The Labor Department issued an annual inflation adjustment of civil penalties in 2019. It calculates the annual adjustment based on the Consumer Price Index for all Urban Consumers (CPI-U). The most recent adjustment is based on the percent change between the October 2019 and October 2018 CPI-U.

The Federal Civil Penalties Inflation Adjustment Act provides a cost-of-living formula for the adjustment of civil penalties. The Act increases penalty levels to those assessed after the effective date of the increase. The final rule became effective January 15, 2020, increasing penalty fees. The changes to the Mine Safety and Health Administration (MSHA) and the Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) penalties take effect immediately and apply to penalties assessed after January 15, 2020.

Penalty Assessment Formula

Penalties for health and safety violations are assessed by MSHA’s Office of Assessments’ formula that considers five factors: the history of previous violations, size of the business, negligence of the operator, gravity of the violation, and the operator’s good faith attempt to correct the violation promptly (if any). The inspector determines these findings from inspections, MSHA records, and information supplied by the operator. The effect of the penalty on the operator’s ability to remain in business is also considered when an operator submits information to the inspector.

OSHA Penalties

OSHA raised its civil penalties by about 1.8% at the beginning of this year. Some of the changes to the OSHA penalties include the following: willful violations where an employer knowingly failed to comply with OSH standards or demonstrated plain indifference for employee safety now has an increased penalty from $49,472 to 49,639 and the maximum penalty increases from $132,598 to $134,937. Violations that are repeated or substantially similar to previous violations have penalties that increase from $132,598 to $134,937.

MSHA Penalties

MSHA violations are the most serious and can impose the greatest fees. The most severe MSHA flagrant violation will now cost $266,275. Employers that fail to abate a citation will incur a maximum penalty of $7,867 per day. Failure to report a fatality or serious injury within 15 minutes will incur a minimum penalty of $6,052.

Contesting Health and Safety Citations

There are multiple options employers can take if OSHA or MSHA cites the company for a violation. If you believe you unfairly received a citation or have evidence to defend your business’ health and safety standards, it may be beneficial to contest the citation. You can contest a citation if you do not believe that your company violated a health and safety order, you believe the violation was improperly classified, you do not believe that the Government gave your company enough time to complete the abatement, or if you believe the assessed penalty was unreasonable.

OSHA Citations must be addressed as soon as possible. Requests to contest OSHA citations must be made within 15 calendar days. Mine operators have 30 days to file a notice of contest with the Secretary of Labor or can wait until a penalty is assessed. After receiving the penalty, the operator has 30 days to file a contest and request a hearing before an administrative law judge of the Federal Mine Safety and Health Review Commission.

There are other factors employers should consider beside the monetary expense of citations. It is also important to consider the consequences of receiving a citation. Workplace safety violations that lead to repeat violations are likely to receive greater fines. Employers are cited for ‘repeated’ violations if they receive ‘substantially similar’ violations anywhere in the nation within the past three years. Employers can also develop poor reputations in the labor community if it consistently receives citations or has employees who continue to get hurt on the job.

Health and Safety Violation Consequences

OSHA and MSHA violations will result in larger penalties for employers. It is important that employers take the necessary steps to improve the health and safety of their most important resources, their employees. A healthy workforce makes employees more likely to work at companies longer. This helps employers save money by not having to train replacements and it limits the penalties that their company may incur from OSHA and MSHA. It is best to be proactive and solve problems and prevent accidents before they occur. If you have been cited for an OSHA or MSHA violation or you anticipate that you will be cited, please contact the experts in workplace safety at Whitcomb Selinsky PC. Consultations are free and you can reach the firm at 303-538-1958.

Your call-to-action heading goes in here. Make it a show stopper!

Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit. Suspendisse varius enim in eros elementum tristique.

Download now

Your call-to-action heading goes in here. Make it a show stopper!

Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit. Suspendisse varius enim in eros elementum tristique.

CTA Button

No thanks, we enjoy struggling!

Get this [offer type] for [targeted persona] to solve your [persona's pain point].

Your [pain point] can be solved by our [your methods] covered in this [offer type].

Get your [offer type]

More than 100+ people have downloaded this FREE [content offer] - give them proof!