Work Place Safety

New Workplace Safety Exam Rule

Posted by Tim Turner on Feb 21, 2018 10:48:14 PM
Tim Turner
Find me on:

REQUEST A CONSULTATION

Workplace safety exam

The Long and Winding Road to the New Workplace Safety Exam Rule for M/NM

You would have to be living under a rock to not have heard about the changes instituted to the workplace exam rule 30 C.F.R. § 56.18002/57.18002. The new rule states:

Examination of working places.

(a) A competent person designated by the operator shall examine each working place at least once each shift for conditions which may adversely affect safety or health. The operator shall promptly initiate appropriate action to correct such conditions.

(b) A record that such examinations were conducted shall be kept by the operator for a period of one year, and shall be made available for review by the Secretary or his authorized representative.

(c) In addition, conditions that may present an imminent danger which are noted by the person conducting the examination shall be brought to the immediate attention of the operator who shall withdraw all persons from the area affected (except persons referred to in section 104(c) of the Federal Mine Safety and Health Act of 1977) until the danger is abated.

The concern with the modified regulation to both large and small mines is MSHA’s apparently expanding (and ambiguous) interpretation of what constitutes a “working place” and how to define exactly when work will be done in such an area. The agency made multiple unsuccessful attempts to expand the definition through litigation. During this process MSHA sought to define a working place as not only any place an employee physically performed work or other duties associated with work but also ANY place throughout the entire mine site where there might be a reasonable expectation of work. This latter interpretation might not have succeeded in litigation but you can bet MSHA inspections will employ this subject approach when enforcing the rules.

That means that any place a miner may work or travel throughout a shift, including stairways, elevators, and seemingly off the path places of a mine that an employee may access but not actually perform work is open to scrutiny. So far it remains unclear as to how this may affect your bottom line in training and manpower costs, and the onus could always shift now that a new director for the agency is in place.

MSHA has stayed the rule again, this time until June 2, 2018, so the agency can address operators’ apprehensions on the compliance component of the rule. The key as always is holding MSHA to a consistent interpretation of how it intends to enforce the rule. A one-size fits all enforcement approach may simply create the opposite result placing heavy burdens on operators and potentially costly fines. MSHA is holding informational compliance assistance visits to M/NM mines. You might consider reaching out to your local MSHA’s field office and request one of these visits if you are looking to enhance your understanding of the rule’s requirements. Our experienced MSHA attorneys also conduct compliance audits and will discuss any concerns you may have regarding the rule and how MSHA intends to enforce it.

New Year Brings MSHA and OSHA Increase in Penalties 

The old saying “only two things in life are for certain – death and taxes” has a couple of new additions. With the passing of each new year, regardless of which political party holds the most sway in Washington D.C. you can bet MSHA and MSHA fines will keep creeping higher.

On January 2, 2018, the Department of Labor, issued its final rule to adjust for inflation (pursuant to the Federal Civil Penalties Inflation Act of 1990 as amended by the Federal Civil Penalties Inflation Adjustment Improvement Act of 2015, if you need to know the regulatory trigger) the civil monetary penalties.  Thus, any MSHA or OSHA citations or orders issued after this date will be assessed at the adjusted level. All citations and orders issued prior to this date and not yet assessed will remain at last year’s monetary levels. Ultimately, the inflation adjustment is the government’s method of keeping the deterrence mechanism associated with penalties intact and encourage regulated employers to continue to strive to ensure work places are safe.

NEW MSHA PENALTIES

MSHA penalties decreased slightly in the last couple of years in some areas (maximum penalties), but that did not equate to a trend as they are on the rise again.  As you can see from the Penalty Conversion Table below, penalties are up on average approximately $20 per point, with the minimum fine (for 60 points or below) moving from $114 to $132 and he maximum penalty (140 points or more) at $70,834. MSHA calculates points based on a mine’s s size, history, negligence, and gravity and converts these points to a dollar amount.

Other penalties of note:

The Minimum Penalty for any order issued under 104(d)(1) of the Mine Act = $2,314.

Minimum penalty for any order issued under 104(d)(2) of the Mine Act = $4,627

Penalty for failure to provide timely notification under 103(j) (accident notification) of the Mine Act = $5,785

Flagrant violations under 110(b)(2) of the Mine Act = $259,725

NEW OSHA PENALTIES

Not to be outdone, OSHA also increased penalties across the regulatory spectrum.

 

2017 Penalties

2018 Penalties

Other than Serious violations:

$12,675

$12,934

Serious violations:

$12,675

$12,934

Repeat violations:

$126,749

$129,336

Willful violations:

$126,749

$129,336

Failure to abate (per day):

$12,675

$12,934

 

Penalties are on the rise and thousands of OSHA inspections are calendared for the 2108 cycle. MSHA will continues its regime of two inspections a year for metal non-metal (non-intermittent) mines and four inspections a year for coal mines. Thus, you as a business owner or mine operator need to be vigilant about safety because you never know (especially with MSHA) when an inspector will come knocking.

If you feel vulnerable in any area of workplace safety, it is important to consult with an experienced OSHA/MSHA attorney to ensure you are in regulatory compliance and ready to endure an inspection cycle. This is especially true under the current wave of unpredictability within the agencies and trying to flip a coin as to the direction they will take – heavy handed enforcement or, as promised, a more compliance-focused approach.

MSHA Table XIV—Penalty Conversion Table

 

Points

Penalty ($)

60 or fewer

$132

61

143

62

154

63

168

64

182

65

197

66

213

67

232

68

250

69

271

70

294

71

318

72

346

73

374

74

404

75

439

76

477

77

514

78

558

79

605

80

655

81

709

82

768

83

833

84

902

85

978

86

1,059

87

1,146

88

1,243

89

1,346

90

1,458

91

1,579

92

1,710

93

1,852

94

2,007

95

2,174

96

2,355

97

2,551

98

2,764

99

2,994

100

3,244

101

3,513

102

3,806

103

4,123

104

4,466

105

4,839

106

5,242

107

5,679

108

6,152

109

6,664

110

7,219

111

7,819

112

8,472

113

9,178

114

9,942

115

10,769

116

11,666

117

12,638

118

13,691

119

14,832

120

16,066

121

17,405

122

18,854

123

20,425

124

22,127

125

23,967

126

25,964

127

28,128

128

30,470

129

33,008

130

35,757

131

38,735

132

41,961

133

45,455

134

49,081

135

52,706

136

56,333

137

59,957

138

63,583

139

67,208

140 or more

70,834

 

Topics: workplace safety exam

Government Contracting is not for the uninformed

Tune in here for the latest in legal news surrounding government contracting

Whitcomb Law, PC is dedicated to helping government contractors extract all the benefits that can be derived from doing business with federal, state, and local governments.  We strive to provide content on this blog that is up-to-date, relevant, and easy to read.  We enjoy reading your feedback especially when it helps us improve the way in which we serve you.

Our sources of information include

  • Recent rulings by the Court of Federal Claims
  • FAR Council
  • SBA rule makers
  • Center for Verification and Eligibility
  • News media
  • Our Clients

Subscribe to Our Legal Blog

Recent Posts

Posts by Topic